Data About Music
February 27, 2011 4 Comments
By popular acclaim, here is some DATA for your DATA processing pleasure. Because nothing says music and artistry appreciation like DATA!
Out of curiosity – or simply because I’m just the sort of nerd to do something like this – I threw my iPod listening history into a pivot table and, where necessary, grouped artists together by one-degree-of-separation associations (for example the top item, which is 1/6th of what I have ever listened to, are all groups that contain Jack White, Brendan Benson, or both).
I think it’s clear this shows me to be a not-well-rounded, non-diverse music listener of high order, not likely to impress a SWPL diversophile anytime soon (for one thing, the list is very white. No Kanye West whatsoever! In fact, I think the only nonwhite you’ll be able to find below is a Brazilian, singing in Portguese – singing David Bowie songs).
Measuring this way (by number-of-songs-listened), a third of my listening is accounted for by essentially three acts, and fully half of what I listen to ultimately comes from seven sources: the aforementined White/Benson axis, the Canadian band Sloan, Tim Rogers or his band You Am I, Dr. Frank or his band the Mr. T Experience, Green Day or the albums they’ve released incognito, the Easybeats (? I guess because they’re the canonical iTunes band – also, because their songs are short, it’s easy to rack up listens), and various projects having something to do with what I still think of as my favorite band of all time, Redd Kross. It’s even less diverse than it appears, because there are numerous incestuous collaborations with the preceding that I probably haven’t accounted for (for example, for reasons too boring to go into if you don’t already know them, one could justify merging Jason Falkner into the Brendan Benson category, the Posies in with Big Star, the Muffs and the Mr. T Experience, Beck and Redd Kross, etc.) I just noticed that I didn’t merge Fountains of Wayne with Tinted Windows, but kinda should have. Then of course you could expand the metric: didn’t Redd Kross tour with Teenage Fanclub? And didn’t they cover a Shangri-Las song or two?
But I’ll spare you.
Races: white, white and white. Countries: U.S., Canada, Australia, and (further down) a bunch of Englands.
Music: Rock and/or roll.
(Compare and contrast: President Obama’s supposed iTunes playlist circa 2008. Couldn’t find a more recent one, presumably because whatever interns a guy like that has to construct things like this have been too busy to brainstorm, agree on, and focus-group such a list recently…)
The full list is below (for brevity, I’ve truncated a long tail of one-play-wonders, but this shows 98% of all plays), summarized by number-of-songs-played, as a percent of the total. And before you say it, I already know what you’re thinking:
You’re thinking, “FASCINATING”.
| Grouping | Total |
| White Stripes/Raconteurs/Brendan Benson/Dead Weather | 16.8% |
| Sloan | 9.5% |
| You Am I/Tim Rogers | 6.0% |
| The Mr. T Experience/Dr. Frank | 5.7% |
| Green Day/Foxboro Hottubs | 5.0% |
| The Easybeats | 3.9% |
| Redd Kross/Malibu Kids/Anna Waronker | 3.8% |
| Rocket From The Crypt | 3.2% |
| Elliott Smith | 3.2% |
| ex-Jellyfish (Jason Falkner/Roger Manning/TV Eyes) | 2.9% |
| The Shangri-Las | 2.2% |
| Weezer | 2.2% |
| Warren Zevon | 2.1% |
| Fountains Of Wayne | 2.1% |
| Teenage Fanclub | 1.9% |
| Macklemore | 1.8% |
| The Muffs | 1.7% |
| Tbilisi Symphony Orchestra & Jansug Kakhidze | 1.4% |
| Mike Patton | 1.4% |
| Matthew Sweet | 1.4% |
| Gene Clark | 1.3% |
| The Hi-Fives | 1.2% |
| Big Star | 1.1% |
| Sam Roberts | 1.1% |
| CAKE | 1.0% |
| Weird Al | 1.0% |
| The Vandals | 1.0% |
| Pulp | 0.9% |
| Superdrag | 0.9% |
| ex-Jayhawks (Gary Louris, Mark Olson) | 0.8% |
| Joan Jett & The Blackhearts | 0.8% |
| Beck | 0.8% |
| Squeeze | 0.8% |
| T.Rex | 0.8% |
| Tinted Windows | 0.8% |
| Seu Jorge | 0.8% |
| The Dickies | 0.7% |
| Sweet | 0.7% |
| Suede | 0.7% |
| David Holmes | 0.6% |
| Utah Symphony Orchestra & Maurice Abravanel | 0.5% |
| Badfinger | 0.5% |
| Alphaville | 0.5% |
| Spacehog | 0.5% |
| John Grant | 0.3% |
I like this. This kind of stuff is fun to me.
My iTunes list (anything with more than 10 plays):
Amoeba – Adolescents
Bloodstains – Agent Orange
Too Young To Die – Agent Orange
32 Flavors – Alana Davis
Lamentate – Arvo Part
Black River – Amos Lee
Back to Black – Amy Winehouse
Trouble Man – Angie Stone
I Bet You Look Good On The Dance Floor – Arctic Monkeys
This Can’t Be Love – Art Tatum
The Warmth of the Sun – Beach Boys
Fire on the Moon – The Bellrays
Sweet Georgia Brown – Bennie Goodman
Blue In Green – Bill Evans
Rain, Rain – Bill Frisell
Ain’t Like You – Blood for Blood
Buckets of Rain – Bob Dylan
Blood in My Eyes – Bob Dylan
I Believe in You – Bob Dylan
Put it On – Bob Marley
River Man – Brad Mehldau
Steal Away – Brian Eno
Pueo, Tara, and Me – Brother Noland
Crazy Bitch – Buckcherry
A Carrot Is As Close As a Rabbit Gets to a Diamond – Captain Beefheart
Love is Blindness – Cassandra Wilson
Koko – Charlie Parker
Dirt Floor – Chris Whitley
Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm – Crashtest Dummies
Just Like Heaven – The Cure
Sally’s Song (from Nightmare Before Christmas) – Danny Elfman
Under Pressure – David Bowie and Queen
I Will Follow You Into The Dark – Death Cab for Cutie
Groove is in the Heart – Dee-Lite
Society – Eddie Vedder
Hiphopopotamus – Flight of the Conchords
How to Save a Life – The Fray
Manimal – The Germs
Orphan Girl – Gillian Welch
Ripple – Grateful Dead
The Eternal – Grant Lee Phillips
Good Riddance – Green Day
Court and Spark – Herbie Hancock and Norah Jones
Thing of Beauty – Hothouse Flowers
Bella Luna – Jason Mraz
Dream Brother – Jeff Buckley
Are You Gonna Be My Girl – Jet
The Way – Jill Scott
Rooftops of Vienna – Joe Zawinul
Courage – Joshua Redman
Right to Be Wrong – Joss Stone
I Loves You Porgy – Keith Jarrett
The Wind – Keith Jarrett
Why Don’t You Look Into Jesus – Larry Norman
Buckets of Rain – Maria Muldahr
King Without a Crown – Matisyahu
Francisco – Milton Nascimento
Missed the Boat – Modest Mouse
Heart of Mine – Norah Jones
Maybe I’m Amazed – Paul McCartney
Crazy Mary – Pearl Jam
Sunshine on Leith – The Proclaimers
I’ve Been High – REM
Nude – Radiohead
Take the Power Back – Rage Against the Machine
Mahler Symphony No. 3
Words Just Get in the Way – Richard Ashcroft
Suniga – Richard Bona
Stewart’s Coat – Rickie Lee Jones
Saint of Me – Rolling Stones
Oh Yeah – Roxy Music
Daddy Bug – Roy Ayers
I Taught Myself How to Grow Old – Ryan Adams
Come See What Love Has Done – Seal
Estate – Shelly Berg Trio
Goldberg Variations – Simone Dinnerstein
Galapagos – Smashing Pumpkins
Chasing Cars – Snow Patrol
Phantom Song – Son of the Velvet Rat
Holes – Son of the Velvet Rat
In the Meantime – Spacehog
I Wish – Stevie Wonder
Open Season – Stuck Mojo
Garden Grove – Sublime
Janitor – Suburban Lawns
Uh-oh Love Comes to Town – Talking Heads
A Pillar of Salt – The Thermals
Invisible Mobile – Tin Hat Trio
Sea Breeze – Tyrone Wells
When I Look at the World – U2
Everything I Am – Up the Dose (Muddy Stardust)
Wild Honey – Van Morrison
Haunts of Ancient Peace – Van Morrison
Stars – Simply Red
Lose Yourself – Eminem
The Drugs Don’t Work – The Verve
The Juggler – Weather Report
In a Silent Way/Waterfalls (Live) – Weather Report
Confians – Weather Report
Adios – Weather Report
Factory Girl – Whiskeytown
Tomorrow People – Ziggy Marley
I would do something like this but my iPod stats are no longer a clean sample, because we use the thing at the hockey rink during breaks in the action. It would skew heavily towards all the songs: A) with a beat from B) well-known acts. (The guy at the scorer’s table doesn’t trust half the off-beat stuff I have that would work just fine.) So as a measure of the best 20-second segments, sure, but as a measure of what I most enjoy listening to, it’s flawed.
I always wonder if there’s inevitably a skew in any statistics like this anyway, because of what iTunes does and doesn’t count as a ‘listen’…
Say I like the first two minutes of a song but skip after, is that a ‘listen’?
Hm. Good point. I think the song has to finish to “count.”
I guess you talked me into it.